Charlottesville Needs More Nerds, Part Deux
Eric ran into some fellow Darden grads, Adam Healey and Charles Seilheimer yesterday at a local coffee shop because he was lured into a conversation about Ruby, Twitter, and Web 2.0 goodness. The discussion led me to go check out their blog, and I found an excellent article about the ingredients necessary for creating the right environment to foster startups.
We run into the same issue that Adam brings up–there are not enough nerds in this area. While we certainly are comfortable leading in a location independent enterprise (the subject of our talk at OSCON 2006), having most of your people co-located does reduce managerial burden on cat herding. It’s not quite as easy to have a look over the shoulder to iron out a gnarly coding problem when your team is spread across three continents as it is when you’re sitting next to each other in a bullpen.
There are other items coming up on the horizon which further point out the need for more nerds (besides the need to keep Charlottesville’s coffee shop economy booming):
–The National Ground Intelligence Center is growing. The Global War On Terror is one that focuses on using technology to interdict the bad guys before they can do harmful things to us. The National Ground Intelligence Center is one of the main nexuses of information collection and analysis. Until we beat the bad guys, the NGIC is going to continue to get business, and it needs nerds to help gather that technology.
–The Defense Intelligence Agency is coming to Charlottesville. They’re bringing about 1,000 jobs to the 29 North corridor, and that doesn’t include everything needed to support them (like coffee shops). Just like the National Ground Intelligence Center, the Defense Intelligence Agency relies on nerds to make sense of signal intelligence and human intelligence. There are currently not enough nerds to go around.
–The surplus of nerds from the Value America days has worked itself through the system. Right after Value America closed shop, the programmers from the company had time on their hands. Many of them started up ventures. However, venture capital money dried up, and they were forced to, for the most part, find “real” jobs. The days when labor was plentiful are no longer in the Charlottesville region because the Value America refugees have become absorbed by the greater economy.
–Venture capital deals are on the rise. The number of deals is up, but the average per deal is down. This means that startups have to focus more on delivering the goods and less on the posh offices. In order to make this happen, startups will need good, solid nerds to get to market faster and bring in revenues more quickly. Nice chairs do not bring in revenue. The Virginia Piedmont Technology Council – Charlottesville Venture Group is working with the City of Charlottesville to determine a strategy to bring technology-based businesses into the central Virginia region. Technology companies are not going to want to come to a place where there are not enough workers to fulfill their needs. As it is, existing technology employers who are looking to grow are having significant trouble growing organically with hometown growth. The growth of the contractor community around the National Ground Intelligence Center is being pumped by imported talent with people moving in from the D.C. area rather than with people in Charlottesville. When the Defense Intelligence Agency comes down, it will be the same story.
So, how to get more nerds to Charlottesville? Adam touched on one step in his blog article, which was focusing on improving the quality of the engineering school at the University of Virginia. He makes a fine suggestion about making a game-changing move and shelling out millions to bring in the rock star professors to draw more students and improve the quality of output at UVa. While this will work in the long run, it will take time for the trickle down effects to happen. What else can we do?
–Give the incubators some teeth. While Charlottesville has incubators such as the Batten Institute and Spinner Technologies, they really don’t provide enough of a runway for entrepreneurs to solidify and implement their ideas. Trying to live on a $1,000 a month stipend while slaving away on your laptop for 25 hours a day simply will not cut it in Charlottesville. The cost of living is too high. Not every great nerd has a burning desire to live on ramen and rice cakes for two years while trying to make his great idea a reality. The reality is that great nerds can get jobs which pay them well, and most of those jobs are not in Charlottesville, Virginia. So, in order to draw in the great nerds to the small businesses and the entrepreneurial ventures which will lead to the next big employment opportunities, the incubators have to put significant investment into the worthy incubator seatholders. This is not so that we can pay nerds tidy sums to do nothing. It is so that we can draw in the motivated great nerds who could otherwise go work for Google. Yes, the incubators will have to blur the line between incubator funding, angel funding, and venture capital funding, but otherwise, the good nerds will go elsewhere, and so will the businesses which employ them and many of their friends.
–Get the local governments in on the action. Universities and foundations shouldn’t be the only ones that are in on the incubator game. The city of Charlottesville, Albemarle county, and the surrounding counties have a vested interest in bringing in more nerds. It seems that most people who are interested in the question would rather have Charlottesville turn into Austin than Aspen, and the governments have to take part in solving that equation. Rather than spending money on Art In Place or on a bus station that takes you nowhere, spend it on things which will breed more employment. If I had $11 million to invest in budding entrepreneurial technology-based companies in Charlottesville, I am willing to bet my mortgage that I could grow jobs in the Charlottesville area and grow the city’s base of tax revenue. The local governments in the area need to partner together, because this isn’t a matter of divvying the pie; it’s a matter of growing the pie. A growing company based in Charlottesville will have residents who live in Albemarle, Green, Augusta, and other counties, who will use goods and services in those areas as well.–Look for public-private partnerships. What major corporation wouldn’t want to have its name attached to the partnership which spat out the next Google? Furthermore, it would get the benefits of the goodwill associated with bringing in new jobs and philanthropy to the region. Everybody wins. The corporation gets to hand-pick the best nerds for its own ventures and gets the positive press that goes along with a public project. The local community gets more money to fund more ventures which bring in more jobs.
–Recruit nerds who live elsewhere. Washington, D.C. is a two hour drive from Charlottesville when the traffic is not abysmally jammed. Naturally, traffic is abysmally jammed all of the time. Nerds (and everyone else) hate traffic jams. Charlottesville does not have them. So, go up to D.C. and talk to the nerds there about the joys and low-stress living that Charlottesville offers. Here’s one group and another if you need a start. We’re talking to their groups, but we are a drop in the ocean. The incubators and local governments need to wade into the waters. By the way, these nerds who you import can also act as great mentors for the young batch of nerds that we should be growing in the University who came in because of the rock star professors we brought in with the $150 million in allocated funds.
–Tax breaks? How about tax credits? The City of Charlottesville is going in the right direction with a 50% tax break for technology-based companies, but it’s not enough. Offer tax credits instead. Don’t worry about losing out on tax revenues, because you’ll make it up in spades from the knock-on effects of having larger employers in your region because of the incentives you offered for them to take up shop and hire employees here. It’s accelerated supply-side economics working for you. If you need more help understanding this, offer to take Dr. Alan Beckenstein out to lunch. You’ll get an amazing return on investment for the $10 that you spend feeding him while he enlightens you.
–Prime the pump with the Piedmont Virginia Community College. For every great nerd we bring in, we need a couple of worker nerds to implement the supernerd’s great strategy. Grow those worker nerds in our own back yard as well. These people can continue in their day jobs while they become worker nerds at night. PVCC has repeatedly stated its willingness to increase the number of technology-based classes it offers, so take them up on the offer. PVCC is a great resource for helping get more nerds here, but it’s an underutilized resource.
Growing a nerd population is not going to happen overnight. However, there is still time to start growing that population before the demand spikes, potential employers become frustrated at the lack of supply, and pick up and move elsewhere, leading Charlottesville to become Aspen without the great skiing. Austin did it through both importing the employers and growing them organically, and it had a great educational system at its back pumping out nerds by the bucketload. It offered incentives for companies to take root, and it offered the people to help the companies execute their missions. By combining programs to bring in and grow the nerd population of Charlottesville as well as generating the employment to keep them here instead of watching a mass nerd exodus every May at graduation time, we can build a vibrant technology community. Otherwise, we are always going to be a second-tier player posing as a first-tier location. The saying in Texas is “all hat, no cattle.” Nerds are the cattle that will drive Charlottesville’s 21st century economy and keep it from becoming an exclusive enclave where few can afford to live and jobs are scarce.
August 31st, 2007 at 12:58 pm
Good post, I think, and a lot of thought. We do have a podcasting network, so maybe that can help? I’ll be happy to facilitate the creation of a Charlottesville Nerds podcast. Drop me a line.
Also, on the subject of the bus center, CTS director Bill Watterson is on record as saying that travel reliability on the buses have improved with the Center. Many routes were adjusted to better fit with the central location, and Market Street is more sightly now that buses don’t wait there during their time synchronization periods. Additionally, The majority of the funding for the center came from state and federal funds.
Another nerdy thing coming about public transportation: Beginning later this year, you’ll be able to track buses in real time, making it a lot easier to use the system.
Finally, a plug for my employer, Charlottesville Tomorrow. C-Ville Weekly recently described us as a “development nerd’s dream because it’s a forum that encourages said nerds to get involved in the many and complicated development issues facing our area.” – Check us out at cvilletomorrow.org!
August 31st, 2007 at 1:10 pm
@ Sean–
Thanks for the reply! I’ll shoot you a note and see if we can get a Charlottesville Nerds podcast going. Maybe the Neon Guild would be interested in helping out?
I’m a fan of public transportation and wistfully hearken back to my days in Germany when I could get anywhere in Europe just by walking down the hill from where I lived and catching a bus. Still, with a $11 million bus transit center, I think they overreached for the efficacy. A cheaper center could have accomplished the same thing and the other money could have been reinvested in the future, be it better infrastructure, or better nerd magnets. The source of the funding, to me, is not nearly as important as the usage. Infrastructure built where nobody is there to use it doesn’t do as much good as things which bring in the people, because then you can build the infrastructure for them. Alas, it’s money already spent which we can’t get back.
I saw the headline for the Cville article, which can be found here.
Is the new bus technology the one developed by Joe Winkler? If so, kudos to him; I remember when he came and spoke to us at Darden.
August 31st, 2007 at 3:10 pm
Jason,
Great rant, and thanks for linking to my post! You make some excellent suggestions. I also do feel like there is some momentum building here in town. Perhaps us nerds and nerd lovers need to get together somehow and come up with a consensus on how to grow the nerd population in town…
August 31st, 2007 at 5:15 pm
Jason, I spoke to the Neon Guild a couple of years ago, and picked up some volunteers at the time. I need to send a note again promoting my site redesign and to remind folks we’re still here!
I’ve not seen a demo of the new technology, but I believe that both UTS and CTS will be using it. It’s being developed by a New Zealand company called Connexion, I believe. I’m following the story for Charlottesville Tomorrow, so I’ll let you know when we got it.
Another way to promote nerds is to promote cvilleblogs.com, and the Charlottesville blogosphere in general. On my personal blog, I’m always writing about nerdy things at least in terms of entertainment. I don’t have the math skills to be a real nerd, I’m afraid.
September 1st, 2007 at 9:08 am
In my observation, competent technologists crave the opportunity to share intellectual DNA with like-minded persons. This is why venues like NFJS and barcamp (and the OS Retreat, I venture to say) work.
The irony is that nerds embrace (and build) technology, yet we don’t have a means yet to achieve synergy without being the same room together. I can approximate it with email, phones and video systems but in my experience it only *after* I’ve established a baseline of good white boarding experience in person.
How is that this is a scratch that our community hasn’t itched? Maybe the issue goes deep into how we build trust relationships. As a species we have been interacting face to face much longer than we have been using digital intermediaries.
You bring up a lot of good thoughts here. If I wanted to attract nerds to the area I would have to give them a compelling reason to believe that we have a critical mass of like minded people clamoring to share the white board. I have less ideas on it than you have but it seems like a classic chicken and egg problem.
September 6th, 2007 at 11:01 am
Jason,
Fantastic post; just the sort of forward thinking we need to foster! There’s good deal of inertia to overcome, but with consistent, persistent, and patient effort, I’m hopeful the tide will turn.
September 10th, 2007 at 9:27 pm
Jason,
I’m at my fifth company up here in Northern Virginia since 1996 and every 2 – 3 years I try to find a way to work for an exciting technology company down south and fail. Northern Virginia sucks the life out of you, but cool tech places (e.g., Austin, Silicon Valley, Boise) are too far from our extended family to be viable (esspecially since we have kids).
Over the years I’ve run into many other Northern Virginian nerds that would die to move to somewhere like Charlottesville and have a stable, existing technology job (with access to the outdoors). So, I’m pretty certain that there is a talent pool ready to move if there was investment to support it. Of course, as you mention above, the challenge is getting the proper investments in place.
One idea I had that wasn’t mentioned above is to try to get Northern Virginia companies to invest in onshore development centers in Southern Virginia. We spend a lot of money paying for offshore development staff which eat up a lot of management/communication time due to cultural, communication, and process differences – it’s nearly impossible to get these folks onsite for a day or two to train them properly. Perhaps, a properly priced onshore development firm could act as a middle ground? (I’d be willing to try it as a customer) A similar concept, something that the Adrenaline Group did in the late 90s, is run a tech R&D shop for companies.
What boggles my mind is that places like Charlottesville are full of old and new money, but where is this all going? Are local million/billionares not interested in investing in technology businesses?
One day it will work out, it’s just a matter of time. In the meantime, I’m trying my hardest to push your cause from up here. Let me know if there’s anything I can do.
November 24th, 2007 at 1:09 pm
Thanks for mentioning us regarding nerd networking in DC. The nerd networking culture is improving slowly in DC. But we don’t have the same verve and energy exhibited by west coast user groups, or European groups. Our local managers seem to be risk-adverse to new tech, new methodologies, new concepts in software development in DC.
With our usergroup we are trying to provide a nexus for the female and male techies that come to DC to share ideas and share resources across political, economic boundaries but I still haven’t found the right catalyst, the right formula. It takes more than pizza and beer here.
We need more success stories, or at least better arguments to coax managers closer to the experiments on the display monitor. Maybe we can develop a Charlottesville–DC synergy that promotes nerd development in both places. What would that be? Not sure yet, but I’m sure we could come up with something. How’s that sound neighbor?